Tracking these 3 retention metrics will provide valuable insights into customer loyalty and help you refine strategies to boost long-term business growth.
Glossary of Terms
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| RPR (Repeat Purchase Rate) | The percentage of customers who make a second purchase after their first. |
| CLV / LTV (Customer Lifetime Value) | The total gross margin (not revenue) you earn from a customer throughout their lifecycle. |
| LTR (Lifetime Revenue) | The total revenue generated per customer (before costs or discounts). |
| CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost) | The average cost to acquire one customer (includes ads, creative, tech). |
| CAC Payback Period | The amount of time it takes to earn back your CAC through gross margin from a customer. |
| Retention Flows | Automated emails/SMS (via Klaviyo or similar) triggered post-purchase to drive repeat behavior. |
| Transactional Messaging | Operational emails (order confirmations, shipping updates) used as marketing touchpoints. |
| Gross Margin | Revenue minus cost of goods sold (COGS) — not including overhead or shipping. |
Table of contents
Why Retention is the Battleground for DTC Brands in 2025
Retention used to be an afterthought. Now it’s the profit center.
Why? Because acquisition is expensive. And every dollar spent on Meta or TikTok ads must eventually pay for itself — fast. If your customers only buy once, your entire CAC model is broken.
Retention is no longer optional. It’s survival.
But here’s the problem:
Most brands track retention metrics wrong.
And when your inputs are off, your strategy’s off.
Let’s fix that.
Retention Metric #1: Repeat Purchase Rate (RPR)
What Most Brands Get Wrong
Shopify and GA4 show you a ratio of new vs. returning customer revenue. That’s helpful — but it doesn’t tell you how many individual customers actually came back.
That’s the actual RPR.
How to Measure RPR Correctly
Here’s how to calculate it like a pro:
nginxCopyEditRepeat Purchase Rate = (# of customers with 2+ purchases) ÷ (total # of customers)Then, segment it by time:
- What % of customers repurchase within 30, 60, or 90 days?
- Are there product-specific RPRs? (Hint: Some SKUs have higher repeat behavior.)
Tools to Use:
- Shopify + Lifetimely
- Klaviyo’s 30/60/90-day repurchase tracking
- Peel Analytics
Strategies to Boost RPR
1. Transactional Messaging (but leveled up)
Don’t waste your order confirmations. These emails get 70–90% open rates.
Add:
- Dynamic product recs (“You might also like…”)
- Loyalty CTA (join VIP, subscribe, refer)
- Free shipping upsell (“Spend $10 more for free express delivery”)
2. Habit Formation Campaigns
Use emails to train customers to use your product regularly.
If they don’t use it, they won’t reorder it.
Examples by vertical:
- Fitness → 30-Day Bodyweight Challenge (Waterdrop’s “Drink More Water” Challenge is 🔥)
- Skincare → “5-Day Glow Routine” with visual progressions
- Coffee → “Brew Better” email + SMS mini-course
3. Bounceback Offers
Send a high-margin, low-discount offer 5–10 days post-delivery.
Example:
“Loved your greens? Here’s 20% off your next pouch — today only.”
Pro Tip: Use Klaviyo to trigger these offers only for first-time buyers who don’t repurchase in 14 days.
High-Impact RPR Boosters
| Strategy | Trigger Time | Tools | Benchmark Boost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Optimized Transactional Emails | Order confirmation | Klaviyo, Postmark | +5–10% clicks |
| Bounceback Email Offers | 5–10 days post-delivery | Klaviyo + Shopify | +8–20% reorders |
| Habit Formation Series | 3 days post-purchase | Klaviyo | +15–25% engagement |
Retention Metric #2: Customer Lifetime Value (CLV/LTV)
What Most Brands Get Wrong
Most eComm dashboards use revenue as a proxy for LTV.
That’s Lifetime Revenue (LTR), not value. What you care about is profit, not top-line numbers.
How to Measure LTV Properly
iniCopyEditLTV = Gross Margin per CustomerWhere:
- Gross Margin = Revenue – COGS – Discounts – Refunds
Then multiply by average purchase frequency over time (e.g., 1.8x purchases per 90 days).
Strategies to Increase LTV
1. Boost AOV at Every Step
- Offer bundles (with built-in margins)
- Use dynamic upsells at checkout
- Offer expedited shipping tiers with profit baked in
2. Increase Purchase Frequency
- Replenishment flows (e.g., “Your serum’s running low”)
- Subscription incentives after first reorder
- Personalized product recs in every campaign
3. Prioritize CLV-Boosting SKUs Analyze products that create long-term customers, not just fast revenue.
→ Segment campaigns by product CLV potential
→ Feature high-CLV SKUs in welcome/post-purchase flows
Tactical Email Ideas to Drive LTV
- “You + Your Refill = Soulmates” – replenishment reminder
- “Don’t forget your Day 30 Check-In!” – habit builder with CTA
- “VIP Upgrade Just Unlocked” – LTV-triggered campaign
CLV Optimization Ideas by Funnel Stage
| Funnel Stage | Strategy | CLV Impact |
|---|---|---|
| First Purchase | Post-purchase onboarding flow | High |
| 30 Days In | Refill offer + habit campaign | High |
| 90 Days In | Loyalty tier unlock or surprise gift | Medium |
| Product Page | Emphasize long-term benefits | Medium |
Retention Metric #3: CAC Payback Period
What Most Brands Get Wrong
Acquisition teams own CAC. Retention teams ignore it. But your CAC payback is the glue between them.
How to Measure It Correctly
objectivecCopyEditCAC Payback = CAC ÷ (Monthly Gross Margin per Customer)Or use days if you track tighter windows.
Your goal? A CAC payback window under 90 days. For high-margin brands? 30–45 is king.
Strategies to Shorten Payback Period
1. Launch High-Margin Add-Ons Immediately
Think:
- Limited-edition merch
- Accessories
- Refills
- Digital add-ons (guides, challenges)
These convert well post-purchase and recoup CAC faster.
2. “Speed-to-Second” Campaigns
Set up automated flows encouraging a second purchase within 14–21 days.
Offer a mystery gift or exclusive bonus on 2nd order.
3. Use SMS + Email in Tandem
SMS boosts urgency. Email drives storytelling.
→ Send SMS 1 hour before email
→ Use it for last-chance reminders and CTA bumps
4. Align Campaigns with CAC Goals
Match retention promotions to ad spikes (e.g., post-BFCM). Drive fast repurchase after acquisition waves.
Final Takeaways: Build a Retention Machine That Pays For Itself
Retention isn’t just about sending emails.
It’s about tightening the feedback loop between acquisition → onboarding → repeat purchases → loyalty.
If your:
- RPR is low → your post-purchase experience is broken
- LTV is weak → you’re not maximizing long-term margin
- CAC Payback is slow → you’re burning cash
Fixing these isn’t just a CRM win. It’s a business win.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What’s a good Repeat Purchase Rate (RPR) benchmark?
Anything above 25% within 60 days is strong for non-subscription products.
2. How often should I be calculating LTV?
Monthly. And segment it by cohort or SKU to find what’s really driving value.
3. Can I improve CAC Payback without cutting CAC?
Yes — by increasing purchase frequency and AOV within 30–60 days post-purchase.
4. What tools should I use to track these metrics?
Lifetimely, Peel, Triple Whale, and Klaviyo. Google Sheets works great for custom CAC payback tracking.
5. Should I separate first-time and returning customer flows?
Absolutely. The messaging, offers, and triggers are completely different.
6. What’s the #1 mistake brands make in retention marketing?
They treat post-purchase as “done.” It’s just the beginning. Without automation and habit-building content, most customers fall off a cliff after order #1.
Ready to Scale Smarter?
At Blossom Ecom, we help brands turn chaotic post-purchase experiences into profit engines.
👉 Want to know your real RPR, CLV, or CAC Payback?
We’ll audit your flows, your data, and your strategy — for free.
Reach out today and get a retention game plan that pays for itself.
Related Articles
- The Ultimate Crash Course Email Marketing for E-commerce Store
- E-commerce Email Marketing: Dos, Don’ts, and Essential Tips for CBD Brands
- Best Practices for Optimizing Email Flows with Klaviyo
- B2B Email Marketing: Building Relationships and Converting Leads
- The Next Frontier of E-Commerce: What’s Coming and How to Prepare
Need help implementing this?
Let us take the hassle of managing your email marketing channel off your hands. Book a strategy call with our team today and see how we can scale your revenue, customer retention, and lifetime value with tailored strategies. Click here to get started.
Curious about how your Klaviyo is performing?
We’ll audit your account for free. Discover hidden opportunities to boost your revenue, and find out what you’re doing right and what could be done better. Click here to claim your free Klaviyo audit.
Want to see how we’ve helped brands just like yours scale?
Check out our case studies and see the impact for yourself. Click here to explore.
Need help implementing this?
Let us take the hassle of managing your email marketing channel off your hands. Book a strategy call with our team today and see how we can scale your revenue, customer retention, and lifetime value with tailored strategies. Click here to get started.
Curious about how your Klaviyo is performing?
We’ll audit your account for free. Discover hidden opportunities to boost your revenue, and find out what you’re doing right and what could be done better. Click here to claim your free Klaviyo audit.
Want to see how we’ve helped brands just like yours scale?
Check out our case studies and see the impact for yourself. Click here to explore.
Read Our Other Blogs
How to Craft Email Newsletters That Build Real Brand Loyalty
Top 3 Best eCommerce Content Management Systems of 2025
Email Marketing vs. Social Media: Which One Should Your Brand Focus On?
How to Craft Email Newsletters That Build Real Brand Loyalty
Top 3 Best eCommerce Content Management Systems of 2025
Email Marketing vs. Social Media: Which One Should Your Brand Focus On?
Attract More Customers: Which Videos to Use in Your Email Marketing and Why
8 eCommerce Customer Service Mistakes You NEED to Stop Making (Like, Yesterday)
Creating The Perfect E-Commerce Tech Stack
Types of Content eCommerce Brands Need in Their Marketing Mix
Ecommerce Email Mistakes: Blossom Ecom Article on How to Stop Sending Bad Emails & Start Making More Money
Boost Your Bottom Line: The Ultimate Guide to Integrating Website and Email Strategies for Your eCommerce Business
6 Powerful Ecommerce Loyalty Program Examples (and How to Build Your Own)
Loyalty-First Guide to Customer Reactivation Email Campaigns
Using Email Marketing to Supercharge Your Loyalty Program
Unpacking Brand and Conversion in E-Commerce Design
13 Scary E-Commerce Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)
How to Reduce Your E-Commerce Bounce Rate and Boost Engagement
Combining Content and Commerce for E-Commerce Success
Email Marketing Tips + Trends
E-Commerce Returns Analysis & Crafting a Profitable Returns Policy
9 Pro Tips for A/B Testing Emails with HubSpot
AI and Email Marketing: The Future is Here
How to Skyrocket Your Email Open Rates and Click-Through Rates
Email Isn’t Dead: 4 Reasons It’s Still a Digital Marketing Powerhouse
Email Marketing Series – #3: Building a Strong Email List
Email Marketing Series – #4: 9 Tips for Creating High-Impact Email CTAs
Email Marketing Series – #2: How to Craft Attention-Grabbing Subject Lines
Email Marketing vs. Social Media Marketing — Which Should I Use?
Email Marketing Series – #1: Crafting an Effective Email Marketing Strategy
Email Open Rate: A Practical Guide
3 Effective Strategies to Make Email Your Marketing Heavyweight Champion
How to Attract New Leads with Video in Your Email Marketing
How to Determine the Profitability of Your eCommerce Website
Multi-Channel eCommerce: The Key to Growing Your Online Business
Understanding eCommerce Conversion Rate & Optimization
How to Optimize Your eCommerce Website for More Conversions
Top 3 eCommerce and Digital Marketing Trends for 2025
Optimizing Your Email Marketing Strategy: A/B Testing Explained
35 Eye-Opening Email Marketing Stats You Need to Know
7 Email Marketing Tips to Boost Your SEO
11 Common Email Marketing Mistakes That Are Tanking Your Conversions (And How to Fix Them)
Strategic SEO Tips for Email Marketing: Boost Engagement and ROI
How to Measure and Increase Email Marketing ROI (Plus Templates That Convert!)
Do Lifecycle Email Campaigns Really Drive Conversions? Here’s What We Found
How to Use Remailing in Your Email Marketing Strategy
B2B Email Marketing: Building Relationships and Converting Leads
Core Email Marketing Flows: 2025 Essentials for Shopify
Top 5 Revenue-Generating Email Marketing Journeys (Straight from a Klaviyo Partner Agency)
The Long and the Short of It: Getting to “Yes” with Email Marketing
10 Email Marketing KPIs Every Marketer Needs to Know
3 Steps to Spring Clean Your Email Marketing Platform
How to Use Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Email Marketing in 2024
How To Create Marketing Emails That Engage Your Audience and Get Results
Why SMS is the Perfect Addition to Any Marketing Mix
Why Personalization is Critical for eCommerce Growth
How to Grow Your Startup’s Email List: Lessons from Daycation
How We Achieved a 27% Winback Rate with a Smart Email Strategy for Dumpling
The Hidden Pitfalls of Email Marketing: Blacklists and Spam Traps
The iOS18 Mail Update: What Marketers Need to Know
Supercharging Customer Journey Automations with Email Touchpoints
Why Your Abandoned Cart Series Needs More Than One Email
13 Simple Design Hacks Using Klaviyo Email Marketing & Shopify
5 Simple Tactics to Grow Your Klaviyo SMS List Without Overcomplicating Things
Why Klaviyo SMS Crushes Other SMS Providers (And How Ignoring It Costs You Revenue)
10 Klaviyo Strategies That Drove Over $50 Million for Our Clients
Email Marketing Management for eCommerce: A Real Guide
Email Marketing 101: How to Create Emails That Convert
Shopify Email Marketing: Campaigns + Automations That Actually Grow Sales
7 eCommerce Trends to Watch in 2025
The Complete Guide to Winning at B2B eCommerce in 2025
Answering YOUR Email Marketing Questions
What Is Email Marketing and Why Does It Work So Well?
5 Steps Toward a Successful Email Marketing Campaign
8 Proven Strategies to Build Your Email Marketing Lists in 2025
How to Supercharge Your Social Media with Email Marketing
The No-B.S. Guide to Ecommerce Email Marketing
How Email Can Power Your Customer Loyalty
How Much Does Email Marketing Cost in 2025?
Email Marketing 101: How to Create Emails That Convert
Create a Winning Welcome Email Strategy
How to Revitalize Your eCommerce Sales in the New Year
Customer Survey Emails: Finding the REAL Reason People Aren’t Buying
E-commerce Email Marketing: Dos, Don’ts, and Essential Tips for CBD Brands
The Ultimate Crash Course Email Marketing for E-commerce Store
How to Measure the Success of Your Email Marketing Strategy
How to Run A/B Tests in Email Marketing
9 Pillars of Email Marketing Success
Rethink Customer Loyalty: 7 game-changing strategies to retain customers
Good Email Marketer vs Bad Email Marketer
What is MMS and Why You Should Start Now
Why SMS is the Marketing Channel of the Future
EDM Marketing vs Email Marketing: What’s the Difference?
Case Study: How Smart Klaviyo Email Segmentation Boosted Conversions by 323%
6 Marketing Strategies to Future-Proof Your Marketing
Mastering Klaviyo Email Design: 11 Tips That Actually Work
How to Customize Shopify Email Templates Quickly and Efficiently
The Next Frontier of E-Commerce: What’s Coming and How to Prepare
Three Steps to Increasing Your Marketing Email Open Rates
Best Practices for Optimizing Email Flows with Klaviyo
Email Marketing ROI: The Most Reliable Revenue Engine You’re Not Fully Using
Conquering the Gmail Inbox: How to Keep Your Emails Out of the Junk Folder
Refreshed Blog: “SMS Marketing for E-commerce: A Straightforward Guide”
Not Sure Where to Start?
Let's find the biggest retention opportunities in your business. Get a free Klaviyo audit or retention consultation.
